James & Cranwell luxury hospitality executive search

FOLLOW US

How to Hire a Luxury Hotel General Manager

The general manager is one of the most consequential appointments an owner or operator makes. The right GM sets the service culture, protects the brand and delivers the numbers; the wrong one can set a property back for years. This guide sets out how the best owners and operators approach the search, wherever the hotel is in the world.

Discuss a search

1. Start with the brief, not the job description

A job description lists duties. A brief explains what the hotel needs from its next leader, and that is what determines who will succeed. Before approaching anyone, agree answers to four questions:

  • Where is the property in its life? Pre-opening, ramp-up, repositioning and steady-state operation each call for a different kind of leader.
  • What does success look like at 12 and 24 months? Be specific: guest scores, market share, profitability, team stability, a successful opening.
  • Who does the GM answer to? In a managed hotel the GM is usually employed by the operator but works closely with the owner and its asset manager, and the owner often has approval rights over the appointment. Misaligned expectations between the two are one of the most common reasons appointments fail.
  • What are the fixed constraints? Brand standards, budgets, local regulations and the culture of the existing team all shape the role.

2. Define the profile you actually need

Two GMs with similar CVs can be very different leaders. The most useful distinctions are usually these:

  • Opening versus operating experience. Opening a hotel means building systems, recruiting a full team and launching under scrutiny. Many excellent operators have never done it, and many strong opening GMs prefer to move on once a hotel is stable.
  • Branded versus independent. Leaders from global brands bring discipline, systems and depth of support; leaders from independent properties are used to working with fewer resources and closer to the owner. Each can succeed in the other setting with the right brief.
  • Rooms-led versus food-and-beverage-led. Where restaurants and bars drive the hotel’s reputation and revenue, an F&B-literate GM is essential.
  • Market knowledge. Cultural fluency, languages and an understanding of local labour markets, licensing and owner expectations matter more in some destinations than others.
  • Commercial depth. A luxury GM today must read a P&L, work with revenue management and report confidently to owners, not only run an exceptional operation.

3. Look beyond the people who are looking

The strongest candidates are rarely on the market. They are running successful hotels, and they will only consider a move for the right owner, brand and opportunity. Reaching them takes direct, discreet approaches, often across borders.

It is also worth widening the field deliberately. Hotel managers ready to step up, GMs of comparable properties in other markets and leaders from adjacent luxury sectors can all be the right appointment, provided the brief supports it.

4. Assess what the CV cannot tell you

Interviews alone rarely reveal how a GM will lead. Combine:

  • Structured interviews involving both the owner and the operator, so that everyone is assessing against the same brief.
  • A practical case built on the hotel’s real situation: a budget, a guest-satisfaction challenge or an opening plan.
  • Time at the property, meeting the team where confidentiality allows, and experiencing the hotel as a guest would.
  • Thorough referencing, including people the candidate has led and owners they have reported to, carried out with the candidate’s consent and in confidence.

5. Plan for timing, relocation and the package

Senior hotel leaders usually have notice periods to serve, and international moves add visas, family relocation and schooling. Plan backwards from the date you need the GM in post, particularly for an opening, where the GM should ideally be appointed well before the team is hired.

Benchmark the package against comparable hotels in the market. Beyond base salary, consider an incentive plan tied to the hotel’s real objectives and, for international moves, housing and family support. In a managed hotel, the package will normally sit within the operator’s grading structure.

6. Make the first 90 days count

Agree a written plan for the first three months: who the GM must meet, which decisions are theirs to make, and how progress will be reviewed with the owner and operator. A well-supported start does more to secure a successful appointment than almost anything else.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Hiring for a famous brand name on the CV rather than for the property’s actual needs.
  • Leaving the search too late for an opening, so the GM inherits a team they did not build.
  • Running separate owner and operator processes that pull in different directions.
  • Underestimating cultural fit, both with the team and with the destination.

How James & Cranwell can help

James & Cranwell is a luxury hospitality executive search firm with offices in Dubai, London and New York. We have completed more than 430 leadership placements over the past three years for clients in more than 40 countries, from general managers to the C-suite. Learn about our executive search work.

James & Cranwell have been a valuable asset to us here at Nobu Hospitality Group. Working with us to secure the finest talent in the global market. Our most recent search was for our General Manager to open our highly anticipated Toronto project which was delivered perfectly.

— Trevor Horwell, Chief Executive Officer, Nobu Hospitality Group

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to hire a luxury hotel general manager?

A focused search often takes around three to four months from an agreed brief to an accepted offer, though this varies by market and role. Then allow for the candidate’s notice period, commonly three months or more at GM level, and, for international moves, time for visas and relocation. For a new hotel, start the search well over a year before opening.

Should the owner or the operator lead the search?

It depends on how the hotel is run. In a managed hotel the operator usually recruits and employs the GM, and the management agreement often gives the owner approval or consultation rights over the appointment, so agree the brief together and involve the owner in the final stages. In a franchised or independent hotel, the owner or its management company leads. Either way, a shared brief prevents one of the most common causes of failed appointments.

When should we appoint a GM for a new hotel?

As early as the opening plan allows. A GM appointed early can shape the opening team, systems and culture rather than inheriting them.

Can a search be confidential?

Yes. Confidential searches are common when a hotel is replacing an incumbent or planning an announcement, and candidates often need the same discretion.

Start a confidential conversation

Tell us about the role or the project. Every enquiry is handled in confidence.

    Explore James & Cranwell